Automated IP Blocklist vs Manual IP Blocking

Stop wasting admin hours blocking IPs manually. See the real cost of reactive IP management versus a $19.99/month automated blocklist.

By CalMax Systems Security Research, founder · Published February 27, 2026 · Updated October 23, 2026

Short answer: blocking VPN brute force IPs by hand is a reactive loop: an attack shows up in your logs, you add deny rules, and the attacker returns from new addresses. An automated EDL blocklist replaces that loop with one firewall rule pointing at one URL, checked for new attackers every 6 hours.

ThreatListPro's list is built from real attacks on live production Palo Alto GlobalProtect VPN portals in the US, so IPs already seen attacking those portals can be blocked before they reach yours. It covers 5.4M+ IPv4 addresses.

The Cost Calculator

Add up the hours your team spends on manual IP blocking during an active VPN brute force campaign. Enter your own numbers below; the defaults are only an example.

Manual IP Blocking: Monthly Cost

Log review and IP identification
hrs/week
$260/mo
Firewall rule creation and testing
hrs/week
$260/mo
Lockout ticket handling
hrs/week
$260/mo
Total manual cost
at $/hour
$780/mo

ThreatListPro: Monthly Cost

Subscription
Includes EDL URL, new-attacker checks every 6 hours, support
$19.99/mo
Setup time (one-time)
Paste URL into firewall EDL config
A few minutes
Ongoing maintenance
The firewall refreshes the list on its own
$0/mo

Side-by-Side Comparison

Manual blocking costs admin time on every campaign. An EDL blocklist costs a subscription and a one-time setup.

Metric Manual Blocking ThreatListPro
Setup Time Ongoing (never finished) A few minutes
Ongoing Work Repeats with every campaign No rule changes after setup
When IPs Are Blocked After they attack you Before they reach you, if already seen attacking our portals
Consistency Depends on who is on shift Checked for new attackers every 6 hours
Multiple Firewalls Rules added on each firewall Same EDL URL on every firewall
Knowledge Required Log analysis, reputation checks, rule changes Paste a URL, bind a deny rule
Monthly Cost Example: ~$780 in labor (3 hrs/week at $60/hour) $19.99
Source of Attacker IPs Your own logs only Real attacks on live production Palo Alto GlobalProtect VPN portals in the US

Workflow 1: Blocking IPs by Hand

Every pass through the manual workflow starts after the attack has already reached your VPN portal:

  1. Notice the attack. Lockout tickets or failed-login alerts arrive. During campaigns we have seen 50+ account lockouts per day on our own portals (see account lockout prevention).
  2. Find the source IPs. Pull failed authentications from the VPN logs and count them by source address.
  3. Check each one. Look it up in WHOIS or a reputation service so you do not block a real user.
  4. Add deny rules. Create address objects, add them to a block rule, commit, and repeat on every firewall.
  5. Document the change for audits and change control.
Attack hits
VPN portal
→
Accounts
lock out
→
Helpdesk
tickets pile up
→
Admin reviews
logs
→
Block IP
on firewall
→
Attacker uses
new IP
→
Repeat

The loop does not end, because attackers pause and return from new IPs. Three problems grow over time:

Scripts that parse logs and push rules through the firewall API cut the typing, but they are still reactive, need maintenance, and can block a legitimate user who mistyped a password.

Workflow 2: Automated EDL Blocklist

With an External Dynamic List (EDL), the firewall fetches the blocklist itself. You set it up once:

  1. Copy your ThreatListPro EDL URL.
  2. Add it to the firewall as an external IP list (EDL, threat feed or dynamic address object, depending on the platform; see the setup guides).
  3. Bind it to a deny rule in front of your VPN portal.
  4. Set the refresh interval. The list republishes every 6 hours.

After that:

Keep watching your own logs: an IP that attacks you but is not on the list yet still shows up there. The blocklist removes the repeat work, not the need for monitoring. To see whether an address from your logs is already listed, use the IP check tool; for the attack pattern behind most of these logins, see password spraying against VPNs.

Frequently Asked Questions

How much time does manual IP blocking take per week?

As an example, consider a team that spends 3 hours a week on manual IP blocking during an active VPN brute force campaign: reviewing logs, checking IP reputation, adding firewall rules, documenting changes and handling lockout tickets. At $60/hour, that is about $780/month in labor. Use your own hours and rate.

What is the difference between reactive and proactive IP blocking?

Reactive blocking means you block an IP after it has already attacked you, so the lockouts and log noise have already happened. Proactive blocking means you block known attacker IPs before they reach your network. ThreatListPro builds its list from real attacks on live production Palo Alto GlobalProtect VPN portals in the US, so an IP already seen attacking those portals can be blocked at your firewall before it reaches your VPN portal.

Can I automate manual IP blocking with scripts instead of buying a blocklist?

Partly. Scripts can parse authentication logs, extract failed-login source IPs and push them to your firewall through its API. That is still reactive, it needs ongoing maintenance, and it can block a legitimate user who mistyped a password. ThreatListPro costs $19.99/month, needs no scripting, and blocks IPs already seen attacking our own production VPN portals.

Stop Blocking IPs by Hand

Replace manual IP blocking with a curated, auto-updating blocklist. One URL, a few minutes to set up, $19.99/month after 14 days free (no card needed).

Start Free TrialOr test 200 entries first: free, no signup