By CalMax Systems Security Research, founder · Published February 1, 2026 · Last updated: November 1, 2026
Five Kinds of IP Feed a Firewall Can Use
| Kind | Examples | How it reaches the firewall | Refresh | Cost |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Firewall vendor feed | Palo Alto Networks Bulletproof, High risk and Known malicious IP addresses | Built in; content arrives with the firewall's subscription | Daily (Palo Alto) | Requires an active Threat Prevention license |
| Free public list | FireHOL, Spamhaus DROP, abuse.ch Feodo Tracker | Text file URL; some need reformatting or trimming to fit | Varies by list | Free |
| Community / crowd-sourced | CrowdSec, AbuseIPDB | Authenticated download URL or API | CrowdSec: 24 hours minimum on Community, hourly on Premium | Free tiers; paid tiers from $25/month (AbuseIPDB Basic) |
| Focused blocklist | ThreatListPro (VPN login attackers) | One URL with the key in the path; plain IPv4 and CIDR | Checked for new attackers every 6 hours | $19.99/month, 14-day free trial |
| Enterprise threat intelligence | Recorded Future, CrowdStrike Falcon Intelligence, Mandiant, Anomali | API, STIX/TAXII, SIEM and SOAR connectors; IP exports for firewalls | Set by the vendor | Ask the vendor; tiers and terms change |
CrowdSec vs Palo Alto or FortiGate Threat Feeds
They are not the same kind of product, so the choice is usually “which ones together,” not “which one.”
- Palo Alto's own IP lists (Bulletproof, High risk and Known malicious IP addresses) are built into PAN-OS with an active Threat Prevention license. Palo Alto updates them daily from its own research. You can't delete, clone or edit the settings of the malicious IP feeds. Separately, a firewall can use up to 30 external dynamic lists with unique sources across all Security rules.
- FortiGate pulls third-party IP lists as IP address threat feeds (Security Fabric > External Connectors), so it uses CrowdSec, ThreatListPro or any plain-text list the same way, in a firewall policy, or in a local-in policy on FortiOS 7.2.4 and later (CLI; GUI from 7.6.0).
- CrowdSec is a third-party provider. Its Blocklist Integrations give your firewall a hosted HTTPS URL protected by Basic Authentication, which Palo Alto consumes as an EDL and FortiGate as an IP threat feed. CrowdSec documents a 24-hour minimum refresh on the Community tier and hourly on Premium, and a default pull limit of 10,000 IPs per integration.
- The practical difference is where the data comes from. Vendor feeds reflect the vendor's global research. CrowdSec reflects signals from its users' security engines. A focused list such as ThreatListPro reflects one attack type: real attacks on live production Palo Alto GlobalProtect VPN portals in the US.
Threat Feed Pricing and Support Terms
Published tiers vary widely. Examples from the vendors' own pricing pages (checked November 1, 2026):
| Provider and tier | Price | List size or quota | Support terms |
|---|---|---|---|
| AbuseIPDB Individual | Free | Blacklist of up to 10,000 IPs, 5 downloads/day | No guaranteed ticket response |
| AbuseIPDB Basic | $25/month | Up to 100,000 IPs, 100 downloads/day | Ticket response in 3 business days |
| AbuseIPDB Premium | $99/month or $1,068/year | Up to 500,000 IPs, 500 downloads/day | Ticket response in 24 hours, business days |
| CrowdSec Platinum Blocklists | From $1,900/month (SMB) | All CrowdSec blocklists, any number of endpoints | Premium service and support is a $1K/month add-on |
| ThreatListPro Monthly / Yearly / Enterprise | $19.99/month, $200/year, $99.99/month | 5.4M+ IPv4 addresses | Email support; 14-day money-back |
For full intelligence platforms, ask for the SLA in writing: uptime of the delivery endpoint, support response time, and how false positives are corrected. A downloadable list's weak point is its URL: if a refresh fails, Palo Alto keeps using the last list it retrieved, so an outage freezes protection rather than removing it. Check how your own firewall behaves.
Free Public Lists: Useful, With Care
Free lists such as FireHOL Level 1 and Spamhaus DROP are valuable community resources, but they cover general malicious activity (spam, malware hosting, hijacked networks), not VPN logins specifically. Check two things before loading one: that it fits your firewall's EDL capacity, and that it doesn't include shared cloud or CDN ranges your users need.
Where ThreatListPro Fits
ThreatListPro is a focused blocklist: 5.4M+ IPv4 addresses from real attacks on live production Palo Alto GlobalProtect VPN portals in the US, checked for new attackers every 6 hours. The same list works as a Palo Alto EDL and a FortiGate threat feed, with separate formats for SonicWall and Sophos. Its limits are deliberate:
- It targets VPN and login attackers only. It doesn't cover malware, command-and-control or phishing.
- It is IPv4 only, with no STIX/TAXII, scores or attribution.
- It complements MFA and account lockout; it doesn't replace them.
Which to Choose
Start with your firewall vendor's feed when:
- You already pay for the subscription (Threat Prevention on Palo Alto)
- You want broad coverage with no extra URL to manage
Add a free or community list when:
- You want broad general-purpose blocking and can check capacity and false positives yourself
- You run CrowdSec engines already, or a daily refresh is enough
Add ThreatListPro when:
Buy enterprise threat intelligence when:
- You have analysts who will use context (attribution, confidence, TTPs) in investigations
- You need domains, hashes and SIEM/SOAR integration, not just firewall IPs
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the difference between a blocklist and a threat feed?
A blocklist is a list of IP addresses a firewall downloads and blocks. A threat feed is a broader intelligence product that can include IPs, domains, URLs, file hashes and context such as confidence scores and attribution, often delivered over an API or STIX/TAXII. Firewalls use the IP part, so a blocklist is the firewall-ready form.
How does CrowdSec compare to Palo Alto threat intelligence feeds?
Palo Alto's predefined IP lists are built into PAN-OS with an active Threat Prevention license and are updated daily from Palo Alto's research. CrowdSec is a third-party provider whose Blocklist Integrations give the firewall a Basic Auth URL that Palo Alto uses as an external dynamic list; CrowdSec documents a 24-hour minimum refresh on its Community tier and hourly on Premium. You can use both, each in its own rule.
How much does a threat intelligence feed cost?
Free public lists cost nothing. AbuseIPDB lists Basic at $25/month and Premium at $99/month or $1,068/year. CrowdSec lists Platinum Blocklists from $1,900/month for SMB. ThreatListPro is $19.99/month or $200/year. Full intelligence platforms are priced by the vendor, so ask for current terms.
Can I use multiple blocklists at the same time?
Yes. Firewalls support several external dynamic lists at once; on Palo Alto, up to 30 with unique sources across all Security rules. Every entry in a list used in policy counts toward your firewall's EDL capacity, so check capacity and overlap, and put each list in its own rule so you can see which one blocks.
Are free IP blocklists safe to use on a firewall?
Usually, with checks. Confirm the list fits your firewall's capacity, that it doesn't include cloud or CDN ranges your users rely on, and that you can exclude a wrong entry quickly. Free lists are general-purpose, so they rarely target VPN login attackers specifically.
Sources
- Palo Alto Networks: External dynamic lists (predefined IP lists, Threat Prevention license, 30-list limit)
- CrowdSec: Blocklist Integrations (Basic Auth URL, refresh by tier, pull limit)
- CrowdSec: Palo Alto integration
- CrowdSec: Fortinet integration
- CrowdSec pricing
- AbuseIPDB pricing
- Fortinet: Use an IP address threat feed in a local-in policy